When the Grip Fails: Understanding Stripped Screws and Your Cordless Drill
There are few things more frustrating in DIY and repair than a stripped screw. That moment when the screwdriver bit spins uselessly within the screw head, refusing to budge the fastener, can bring a project to a grinding halt. Fortunately, your trusty cordless drill, often the instrument of the stripping itself, can also be your most powerful ally in fixing it. This guide will walk you through various methods, from simple to slightly more involved, to successfully remove or salvage that stubborn stripped screw using your cordless drill.
Must-Have Tools in Your House If You Work Regularly
What Exactly is a Stripped Screw?
A stripped screw, also known as a cam-out or rounded-out screw, occurs when the slots or recesses in the screw head (like Phillips, Torx, or flathead) become damaged and no longer provide enough grip for a screwdriver bit. This often happens due to:
- Using the wrong size or type of screwdriver bit.
- Applying excessive force or the wrong angle when driving the screw.
- Driving a screw into a very hard material, causing the bit to slip.
- The screw head being made of softer metal.
- Repeatedly trying to loosen or tighten a screw that is already stuck.
Why Your Cordless Drill is Your Go-To Tool
Your cordless drill offers a combination of power and precision that makes it ideal for tackling stripped screws. Its variable speed control allows you to start slowly and increase speed as needed, while its torque settings can help prevent further damage. With the right attachments and techniques, your drill can be the key to extracting or even re-using those compromised screws.
Method 1: The Rubber Band/Steel Wool Trick (Low-Tech, High Success)
Before you resort to more aggressive methods, try this incredibly simple yet surprisingly effective technique. It relies on creating extra friction between the screwdriver bit and the damaged screw head.
The Simple Steps:
- Gather your materials: You’ll need a wide rubber band (the thicker, the better) or a small piece of steel wool.
- Prepare the screw head: Place a section of the rubber band or a small wad of steel wool directly over the stripped screw head.
- Insert the screwdriver bit: Carefully insert your screwdriver bit into the screw head, pressing it firmly into the rubber band or steel wool.
- Engage the drill: Set your cordless drill to a low speed and in reverse (for removal).
- Apply gentle pressure: Slowly and steadily apply downward pressure on the drill while engaging the trigger. The rubber band or steel wool should fill the stripped void, providing the bit with the necessary grip.
- Slow and steady wins: If you feel the bit start to catch, continue to apply gentle outward pressure while unscrewing. If it slips, stop, readjust, and try again.
When This Method Shines:
This is an excellent first step for screws with minor stripping, especially in softer materials. It’s non-damaging to the surrounding material and requires no special tools beyond common household items.
Method 2: Using a Screw Extractor Bit (Designed for the Job)
Screw extractor bits are specifically designed to remove damaged screws. They typically have two ends: one for drilling a pilot hole and the other for extracting the screw.
Key Facts: Screw Extractor Bits
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Type | Double-ended drill and extractor bits. |
| Material | Hardened steel for durability. |
| Functionality | Drills a pilot hole, then reverses to grip and extract. |
| Compatibility | Works with most cordless drills. |
| Sizes | Available in various sizes for different screw types and sizes. |
How to Use Screw Extractor Bits:
- Select the right size: Choose an extractor bit set appropriate for the size of your stripped screw.
- Set your drill: Set your cordless drill to its lowest speed setting and reverse (unscrew) mode.
- Drill the pilot hole (if necessary): Some extractor bits require you to drill a small pilot hole into the center of the stripped screw head. Use the drilling end of the bit (or a separate small drill bit of a similar size) to create a clean hole. Ensure you drill straight.
- Flip the bit: Once the pilot hole is drilled, flip the extractor bit to the extraction end.
- Insert and engage: Insert the extraction end into the pilot hole. Apply firm downward pressure.
- Slowly unscrew: Gently begin to unscrew by squeezing the trigger on your drill. The extractor bit’s reverse threading will bite into the screw and hopefully back it out.
- Maintain pressure: Continue to apply steady downward pressure to keep the extractor engaged with the screw head.
Pros and Cons of Screw Extractor Bits
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Highly effective for significantly stripped screws. | Requires purchasing a specialized bit set. |
| Designed for this specific purpose. | Can be tricky if the pilot hole isn’t drilled perfectly centered. |
| Relatively quick once you get the hang of it. | May not work if the screw is extremely rusted or seized. |
Method 3: Creating a New Slot with a Dremel or Cutting Disc
If the screw head is severely damaged, you might need to create a new slot for a flathead screwdriver. This method is more aggressive and requires careful control.
Essential Equipment:
- Cordless drill (or a rotary tool like a Dremel)
- Thin cutting disc attachment (for Dremel or drill)
- Safety glasses (critical!)
- Gloves
- Flathead screwdriver
Step-by-Step Procedure:
- Safety first: Put on your safety glasses and gloves. Ensure the work area is clear.
- Attach the cutting disc: Securely attach a thin metal cutting disc to your rotary tool or drill.
- Set your drill/tool: If using a drill, set it to a medium speed. If using a rotary tool, select a speed that allows for controlled cutting.
- Carefully cut a new slot: Position the cutting disc on the edge of the stripped screw head. Gently and steadily cut a new, straight slot across the diameter of the screw head. Aim to cut deep enough for a flathead screwdriver to get a good grip, but avoid cutting into the surrounding material.
- Clear debris: Once the slot is created, use a brush to clear away any metal shavings.
- Use a flathead screwdriver: Insert a well-fitting flathead screwdriver into the new slot.
- Engage the drill (optional, for added torque): You can sometimes use your drill with a screwdriver bit, set to low speed and reverse, applying downward pressure to turn the screw. Alternatively, use manual force with the flathead screwdriver.
- Extract the screw: Slowly and steadily turn the screwdriver to extract the screw.
Important Considerations:
- This method is best for screws that are not countersunk too deeply, allowing you access to the top of the head.
- Practice on a scrap piece of metal if you’re new to using cutting discs.
- If the screw is very small or the surrounding material is delicate, this method might be too risky.
Method 4: The Pliers Grip (For Protruding Screws)
If the stripped screw head is still protruding enough to get a grip on it, your cordless drill can assist in providing the necessary torque, but the primary tool here will be pliers.
When This Method is Suitable:
This is ideal for screws where the head is raised above the surface, allowing for a firm grip with locking pliers.
Steps to Success:
- Secure the grip: Use a pair of locking pliers (like Vise-Grips) to clamp firmly onto the outer edge of the stripped screw head. Get the tightest grip possible.
- Position the pliers: Angle the pliers so you can apply leverage.
- Apply outward pressure: Gently try to turn the screw by rotating the pliers counter-clockwise.
- Use the drill for torque (optional): If manual turning is difficult, you can sometimes attach a socket wrench or adapter to the pliers’ handle and then use your drill (set to low speed, reverse) to provide extra turning force to the pliers. Be very careful not to break the screw head off completely.
- Steady and slow: Continue to apply steady pressure. If the screw starts to move, keep turning slowly.
Method 5: Drilling Out the Screw (The Last Resort)
This is the most destructive method and should only be used when all other options have failed. The goal is to drill away the screw head itself, allowing you to separate the pieces.
The Riskiest, But Sometimes Necessary Approach:
Steps to Carefully Drill Out a Screw Head:
- Safety is paramount: Wear safety glasses and gloves.
- Select the right drill bit: Choose a drill bit that is slightly larger than the shank of the screw, but smaller than the head. A metal-cutting drill bit is essential.
- Center the screw head: Use a center punch to create a small indentation in the exact center of the screw head. This will prevent the drill bit from wandering.
- Set your drill: Set your cordless drill to a medium speed and forward (drilling) mode.
- Drill the screw head: Carefully and slowly begin drilling directly into the center of the screw head. Apply steady, even pressure. The aim is to drill through the head, effectively severing it from the screw shank.
- Observe closely: As you drill, the screw head should eventually break free. Stop drilling as soon as the head is removed.
- Remove the material: Once the head is gone, you can typically lift the piece of material that was held by the screw. The remaining screw shank will be left in its hole.
- Remove the shank: The remaining shank can often be gripped with pliers and unscrewed, or you may need to drill it out completely.
Troubleshooting and Prevention
Even with the best intentions, sometimes these methods require a bit of finesse. Here are some tips:
Common Issues and Solutions:
- Drill bit slipping: Ensure you are using the correct size bit and applying sufficient downward pressure.
- Screw not budging: The screw might be seized due to rust or adhesive. Try applying a penetrating lubricant (like WD-40) and letting it sit for a while before attempting extraction again.
- Breaking the screw head off: This is more likely with the drilling method. If the head breaks off, you’ll be left with a shank to deal with.
- Damaging surrounding material: Always work slowly and deliberately. Use painter’s tape to protect delicate surfaces.
Preventing Future Stripped Screws:
- Use the correct bit: Always match your screwdriver bit to the screw head type and size precisely.
- Don’t overtighten: Stop driving the screw once it’s snug. Overtightening is a primary cause of stripping.
- Use the clutch: Many cordless drills have a clutch setting. Use lower torque settings for driving screws, especially in softer materials.
- Pilot holes: For hardwoods or metal, always drill a pilot hole slightly smaller than the screw’s thread diameter.
- Quality fasteners: Invest in good quality screws; their heads are often made of harder metal.
By understanding these techniques and employing a bit of patience, you can successfully overcome the challenge of a stripped screw and keep your projects moving forward. Remember to prioritize safety and choose the method best suited to the severity of the stripping and the materials you’re working with.